Is Meditation Dead?

is meditation dead

It struck us as funny that day that one of our colleagues came in with an experience she had at a restaurant meal with friends recently. When she was talking about wellness with her friends and mentioning meditation practices, the woman declared that “meditation is dead,” meaning passe or not in style anymore. And though we laughed about the ridiculousness of it, it stuck with us. 

Meditation dead?

Is this how some people view meditation or any other nourishing wellness practice–as something that comes in as a trend and then goes away? Of course, there are trends that come and go, usually because they are of the ilk of quick fixes. Meditation, however, is here to stay. 

The practice of it is older than history itself. Research indicates that it has served as a spiritual endeavor for humans since the dawn of our existence. In 2007, psychologist Matt J. Rossano suggested that rituals and meditation practices around campfires between 200,000 and 150,000 years ago played a crucial role in the evolution of human working memory. He posited that the act of “fire-gazing” not only rewired our brains but also enabled the emergence of symbolism and language, fundamentally shaping our humanity.

So, in a way, meditation is in our DNA from ancestors past.

In our latest podcast, we talk about our own practices of meditation and how it doesn’t really need to look or be a particular way. It takes many forms and that’s what makes it completely doable for everyone. We also mention The Wellness Hub and their weekly Wednesday meditation group open to everyone at our space in Red Bank.

*Note: In the podcast Debbie makes an error in attributing a song lyric to Nirvana when it is the song “Machinehead” by Bush

Here’s the transcript:

 

Wendy  00:33

It’s spring, and it’s glorious out right now. And everything is popping. The flowers are just kind of making me high a little bit.

Debbie  00:40

Yeah, for sure. For spring does that it’s so motivating. It’s so, it’s so cheerful, and it gets you wanting to do a whole bunch of stuff.

Wendy  00:50

Just the whole idea of renewal and birth is just really beautiful. If we pay attention, or it can feel like complete chaos.

Debbie  01:00

Yes, I mean, every transition of season feels a little chaotic. But I think that the spring one is especially chaotic, because I think we all feel like we need to be productive and get a bunch of things done.

Wendy  01:11

Oh my gosh, yeah. And in the winter, we’re a little bit more quiet. And just the darkness leads to a little bit more quiet. But the lighter nights, it’s really like I’m still supposed to be doing something, right. So true. It’s harder to wind down when it’s laid out.

Debbie  01:31

It is That’s very true. And the thing about spring, too, is I think, including me, it’s a time where you want to take on new things and take on new habits and say, Okay, this is a good time to start this.

Wendy  01:44

And it is it is.

Debbie  01:45

That’s a great time to start. Yeah.

Wendy  01:48

And we have one number one thing we wanted to talk about today as a habit to start, right. And it stems from a conversation we recently had with someone who claimed that meditation is dead. It’s so passe, it’s gone. It’s over the trend is a trend gone. The trend of meditation is gone. Yeah. And we disagree completely.

Debbie  02:12

Completely! It’s funny, because, yeah, there are so many health trends; there’s so many things that come, don’t necessarily go, but they become popular for a little while. And then everybody tries it. And then it, you know, it doesn’t get it, it kind of goes away from the scope of a lot of people. But there’s a core of people that continue it. Yeah. And perhaps that’s what’s happened with meditation is that it got really popular again. And then that popularity is kind of, you know, it’s not being marketed as much by the wellness people. The fix it people aren’t really marketing it anymore.

Wendy  02:57

Yeah, that’s so interesting. But it’s such a core practice. It’s so ancient, just the idea of stillness and quiet is the best medicine for, you know, practicing the quiet is the best, it’s the best medicine of all in a chaotic time.

Debbie  03:18

Absolutely. And I think the best part about it is you don’t have to be an expert, you don’t have to find a quiet room and sit and stillness for an hour. It’s not like that. It can be like that. It can be. But I would love to get to that point. But I’m certainly not here right now,

Wendy  03:38

I certainly cannot sit in lotus position for an hour. My body just doesn’t do that anymore.

Debbie  03:46

For me, I’m kind of like a meditation snacker. Like, I find moments throughout the day that actually call me to meditate. And so I will take a minute or two or three, to find my breath to scan my body to just find stillness. And that’s my, that’s how I’m meditating these days. I really have not found a practice for more than a few minutes at this point. I will. But I’m practicing right now.

Wendy  04:14

Yeah, so you’re doing these little mini ones. Yeah. Building up the practice. I think that’s beautiful. Because some people have such high expectations because they think it’s supposed to be a certain way. Yeah. And we’ve had clients, multiple clients, say, I’m not good at meditation where it’s not for me. Right?

Debbie  04:32

I’ve heard so many people say that. Yeah.

Wendy  04:36

And first of all, there’s not good or bad meditation, right? It’s just a practice. Yes, it can come and go or it can be a practice that you really foster.

Debbie  04:49

It’s a wonderful habit to begin if you haven’t started it yet. It’s an absolutely wonderful thing to start maybe with 30 seconds, maybe with a minute. You could do it on your own, which is what I do. And sometimes I use an app, if I really want to kind of tune in and hear another person’s voice or another person’s bells or whatever it is that they use on the app to get me meditating. But there are several apps that are out there. Two of our favorite, I think you use Insight Timer,

Wendy  05:25

I use Insight Timer. And I’ve been well, I’m not going to say how long I’ve been doing it–a long time, so much so that it’s the first thing I do. When I wake up. After I go to the bathroom, I sit and I crawl back in bed, and I sit up in bed and I get cozy with my cats. And I meditate, and it might be five minutes, or it might be 25 minutes. It’s just what I’m called to do right at the time. Yeah. And I think for me, allowing myself to do what my body’s calling for–my mind, or my time or my space is calling for each morning without being rigid about it works for me, right now in my life.

Debbie  06:07

Yeah. Right. And, and for me, I would love to do that that would be ideal for me. The other app that I use is called Headspace. I don’t have that lifestyle where I can get out of bed and go to the bathroom and come back into bed because I have a puppy who would really disrupt my meditation if I got back into bed. So that’s not a time that I meditate, I have to finish feeding the cats get getting the dog walked before I can settle back down into meditate for my few minutes for my morning meditation. And it really is just a few minutes before some kind of interruption happens in my house. So yeah, and that’s who the people who say “it’s not for me, I can’t sit still and keep my focus.” Yeah, you know, neither can I. But what I do is I sit there and I get thoughts. I say, oh, there’s that thought. Hi thought! I let go of it for a moment. I’ll get back to you later. And I do that, I can’t tell you how many times that happens in just the three minutes. Exactly. That’s it’s so normal. And I don’t beat myself up about it. Because I’ve learned that that’s just the way my mind works. And it’s happening less, the more I meditate, that happens less. So, the more consistent I am with meditation, the less my mind wanders, and that’s really one of my motivations to keep doing it. Because I noticed that difference. And if I let it go again, I noticed the thoughts come back more often, so for me my motivation to meditate is so that it can get better for me because then I feel better.

Wendy  07:43

Yeah, we feel better when we meditate because the practice gives us a little bit more agency when things come at us in the world. And so when we’ve got these inputs, or when I’m cut off on the parkway on my way to work (my example that I use often). I have become less reactionary, and I know it’s my discipline of meditation and just being with the breath and sitting and sometimes my meditations are walking meditations too. So some people can be silent and go for a walk in the woods or go for a walk by the water or in your community and no iPod or earphones or anything like that. Just silence. Sometimes people take the meditation app with them on a walk– that can work too. I think making your own in any kind of discipline practice is really what we’re trying to encourage people to just start someplace. Do something that creates some sort of, shall we call it, peace within or calmness or reflection or stillness. Maybe some people could send us a note and say, What does meditation mean for you? Or what’s the gift that it gives you?

Debbie  09:05

Yeah, I’ve noticed I’ve said this before, I noticed a big difference in Wendy when she was doing her practice for a while. And it kind of just dawned on me one day when she came into work. And she had said that she sat through traffic. And I noticed a couple of months ago or last year when she would say that she had this tightness and this anger and this time it was more just like “yeah, I sat through traffic.” I noticed the big difference with you. And so it’s sometimes it’s easier to notice a difference in other people. But I’m sure I’m sure that it’s happened with me too in some ways that might not be tangible to me or someone else but it’s I have noticed just by my thoughts changing Yeah, and I’m meditating. So in my practice is fairly new still.

Wendy  09:52

I still feel like a rookie, you know? And I think that beginner’s mind is a beautiful thing, right? It’s got curiosity and playfulness in it. The other thing about meditation on a physiological level is that when we create calm in our body, and in our mind, it resets our central nervous system. And we’re so go, go, go. We’re recording this in spring, when we’re kind of revving up and doing a lot of stuff. And when we’re in fight or flight so often, and we’ve got chaos going on, so often, our bodies are not meant to be in that state, consistently. And so Meditation allows us to reset our central nervous system and primarily through breath. So my biggest thing when I meditate is going to my breath as my anchor. Because that gets me out of my thoughts, and sometimes I put my hand on my heart, and maybe one on my stomach and just to connect with myself. And that’s really helpful. To reset the central nervous system.

Debbie  11:13

One of the things that I do to connect to my breath is, I hear that Nirvana song in my head, “breathe in, breathe out.” *

Wendy  11:23

I never knew that Nirvana* would be part of meditation.

Debbie  11:25

That’s what works for me. So, if you wanted to get started with a practice, you can do it on your own, you can use an app. We also just to let you know about our Wellness Hub that is a brand new thing. We have a colleague, Yvonne Cangialosi, who started the Wellness Hub, which is using this space, this beautiful space we have in Red Bank, where she has events and workshops, all about wellness, and there are a variety of them. So, Wellness Hub, New Jersey, you can go check her out, she has a colleague, who is a Qigong, acupuncture, meditation, he’s got so many things going on. And they hold a regular weekly meditation group here at our office in Red Bank. So check that out, go on to the website, the Wellness Hub, New Jersey, and see what’s there and maybe join that group.

Wendy  12:18

It’s on Wednesday mornings right now. So, if you’re interested or curious and want a safe space, and one a little bit of direction, and to do it in community with other people sometimes is a great way to get started. So we encourage you to check that out. We’ll put the link in the show notes.

Debbie  12:36

Yep. And if you’re wanting to start habits for this spring that will, you know, help you with your wellness and you want a community group to do it with and you have a few friends, we are happy to form a group with you to keep you accountable where we can meet weekly or bi weekly and keep you going on new habits or introduce some wellness ideas to you. We have a book group that’s going to be coming to us as a group, they’re starting as a wellness group. So it’s a great way to grab your friends and to do it together because then you can keep each other accountable when you’re not actually here. So we’re on Zoom too–that’s another way to do it. So if that’s an idea that resonates with you, we’re here. Just check us out.

Wendy  13:19

Thanks for listening and please share. If you know someone who’s said to you, “ah, meditation is passe or not in anymore.”  It’s here to stay. It’s so good for us.